South Daytona Man Charged With Murder After Guest Shot in Face, Affidavit Says

SOUTH DAYTONA, Fla. — A gathering that began at local bars and continued at a South Daytona apartment ended with Robert Shawn “Rob” Panayotis fatally shot in the face early October 28, according to a newly available South Daytona Police Department arrest affidavit.
Justin W. Bryan, 31, called 911 and said he had shot someone, the affidavit states. Officers found Panayotis on the bedroom floor with an apparent gunshot wound to the head. Emergency personnel found no vital signs at approximately 5:46 a.m.
Accounts of the shooting differ
The affidavit says Bryan, Panayotis and their partners met on October 27 and later went to Bryan’s apartment. It describes sexual activity among members of the group before an argument began in a bedroom.
Two witnesses told investigators Bryan retrieved a shotgun from a closet, fired one round into the floor, then shot Panayotis in the face as Panayotis gathered his belongings and zipped a backpack to leave, according to the affidavit.
Bryan gave investigators a different account. He said Panayotis threatened to kill him, struggled with him over the shotgun and lunged toward him while reaching for a backpack. Bryan said he fired in self-defense. He also told investigators he never saw Panayotis with a firearm. The two witnesses disputed his account of the threats and struggle.
Investigators reported finding two spent shotgun shells, a shotgun in a gun case and what appeared to be a shotgun blast into the bedroom floor. The affidavit does not resolve the conflicting accounts; those questions will be addressed through the court process.
The affidavit identifies the allegation as second-degree murder with a firearm under Florida Statute 782.04(2). An officer noted that a records system displayed a first-degree murder label in error and clarified that the intended charge is second-degree murder. The police case number is SD261000118, and the Volusia County court case number is 2026 107061 CFDB.
Bryan is presumed innocent unless and until proven guilty in court.
Read the charging affidavit
The three-page document below is the South Daytona Police Department affidavit filed with the Volusia County Clerk. It contains allegations and witness accounts, not judicial findings. Open or download the affidavit.
Sources: Volusia County Clerk case docket; Volusia County Corrections booking record.



