Another Holly Hill Police Report Arrives With Social Security Information Exposed After City Promised Changes
HOLLY HILL, Fla. — A Holly Hill police arrest affidavit supplied to CFL Report contains unredacted Social Security numbers, raising new questions about the city’s handling of sensitive information months after officials acknowledged an earlier disclosure and announced a change in procedure.

Matt Tomasello emailed the three-page affidavit to CFL Report on October 18, 2026, under the subject line “unredacted 707.” His message said, “Here is what HH sent me.” The document identifies the Holly Hill Police Department as the agency, carries case number HH260001937 and concerns an October 6 arrest.

CFL Report reviewed the document and confirmed that three full Social Security numbers and three driver’s-license numbers were exposed. We are publishing a redacted copy, not those identifiers. The publication’s redactions are marked “redacted by CFL Report.”
The distinction between the document and its delivery history matters: Tomasello identifies Holly Hill as the source, but his email does not include the city’s original transmission or a public-records request number. CFL Report has not independently established who released this copy or the date it left the city. It is therefore a second reported disclosure involving Holly Hill, following an earlier disclosure the city expressly acknowledged.
The January acknowledgment
On January 8, 2026, Holly Hill Human Resources Manager Jeaneen Witt emailed CFL Report’s Mark Dickinson about a previously released Port Orange police report. “I wanted to acknowledge that I am the employee who made the error in releasing a document with a social security number on it,” Witt wrote.
Witt said she had not realized the city had received an unredacted copy of the report. She said she had notified the affected person and asked that the information not be shared further. “Joe intends to issue a reprimand to me for this error,” she wrote. The emails reviewed do not establish that a reprimand was subsequently issued.
Witt also said Tomasello believed City Clerk Valerie Manning was responsible, but Manning was on vacation at the time. The acknowledgment was Witt’s, not Manning’s.
The change the city promised
Later on January 8, City Manager Joe Forte emailed Tomasello, copying Dickinson and city staff. Forte said he had investigated the matter that afternoon. He wrote that police staff had advised him the Social Security number should have been redacted. He also described concerns about victim information and said the City Clerk and Human Resources Manager would review Marsy’s Law.
Forte announced a change in who would handle police records: “Moving forward, any police report in the possession of Holly Hill, whether initiated in Holly Hill or by another agency, will be redacted and released by the police department clerks, not city hall staff.”
If the October copy was released by Holly Hill as Tomasello says, it raises a question about whether that procedure was followed and whether the review caught information that needed to be withheld. The records reviewed do not identify who handled the October copy or show whether the city investigated it, notified those affected or took corrective action.
Read the redacted records
View or download the full three-page affidavit, redacted by CFL Report (PDF).
View or download the complete January 8 emails from Jeaneen Witt and Joe Forte (PDF). This PDF renders the original downloaded email messages, including their full plain-text bodies, headers and quoted correspondence; it is not a selection of excerpts.
The purpose of publishing these records is to document the handling of public information without repeating the exposure of private identifiers. No Social Security number or driver’s-license number is being published here.



